FSA vs HSA at Open Enrollment
Same pre-tax idea, opposite personalities. One table, the rules for holding both, then the decision that settles it.
Updated November 2026 · 2026 limits live, 2027 HSA limits official
The short version: if you're healthy and can take an HDHP, the HSA almost always wins long-term — its money never expires. The FSA wins when you need predictable, immediate medical spending with no high-deductible plan in the picture. Many employers let you hold a limited-purpose FSA alongside an HSA for dental and vision.
Open enrollment is the only window (typically now through mid-December) to elect an FSA or switch health plans. Deciding "which account" is really deciding which health plan — the plan you pick decides which accounts you're allowed to have.
The comparison table
| FSA | HSA |
| Eligibility | Any employer plan offers it | Requires HSA-qualified HDHP |
| 2026 limit | $3,400 (health care) | $4,400 self / $8,750 family |
| 2027 limit | TBA (announced each November) | $4,500 self / $9,000 family (official) |
| Money expires? | Yes — year-end, grace period, or $680 carryover | Never — rolls forever |
| Access to full amount | Day one (employer fronts it) | Only what's actually deposited |
| Portable between jobs? | No — usually ends at termination | Yes — it's yours |
| Earns interest / investing | Rarely | Yes — interest and investments |
| Early non-medical withdrawal | Just forfeits what's unspent | Tax + 20% penalty (before 65) |
| Changes mid-year | Locked except life events | Contribute anytime up to tax deadline |
| Employer can contribute? | Rarely | Often — and it counts toward your limit |
Can you hold both at once? The rules that cost people real money
- HSA + general-purpose health FSA = not allowed. Contributing to both in the same months makes you ineligible for HSA contributions those months — every dollar you put in the HSA becomes an excess contribution with a 6% excise tax until corrected. This is the #1 open-enrollment mistake.
- HSA + limited-purpose FSA = allowed and smart. A limited-purpose FSA covers dental and vision only. It preserves your HSA eligibility while giving you pre-tax money for the predictable stuff (cleanings, glasses, contacts).
- Dependent care FSA never conflicts — it's a separate account for childcare, safe to hold with an HSA.
- Spouse wrinkle: your spouse's general-purpose FSA can also disqualify your HSA if their plan covers you. Two-earner couples: check both plans before either of you elects.
The rule that settles it for most people
- Expect steady medical bills (braces, known procedures, young kids, medications)? FSA — elect what you'll actually spend. Pre-tax, simple, gone by year-end. Size the election right.
- Healthy, high-deductible plan, savings beyond this year's deductible? HSA — triple tax advantage, no expiry, investable. Then make the cash rate honest: most HSAs pay a terrible default interest rate. Check what yours pays at HSARates.com →
- Offered both? HSA + limited-purpose FSA (dental/vision only) stacks — pre-tax for the predictable spending, permanent for the rest. Ask benefits if your plan offers the combo.
One exception that changes everything: if your employer's HSA charges monthly maintenance fees or pays 0.01% on cash with no investment option, the "superior" HSA can underperform a plain FSA election in practice. The account type is half the decision — the custodian's terms are the other half.
More on this site
The FSA's biggest weakness, dated.
$4,500 / $9,000 — official.
The HSA interest-rate table.