FSATips.com

FSA vs HSA at Open Enrollment

Same pre-tax idea, opposite personalities. One table, the rules for holding both, then the decision that settles it.

Updated November 2026 · 2026 limits live, 2027 HSA limits official

The short version: if you're healthy and can take an HDHP, the HSA almost always wins long-term — its money never expires. The FSA wins when you need predictable, immediate medical spending with no high-deductible plan in the picture. Many employers let you hold a limited-purpose FSA alongside an HSA for dental and vision.

Open enrollment is the only window (typically now through mid-December) to elect an FSA or switch health plans. Deciding "which account" is really deciding which health plan — the plan you pick decides which accounts you're allowed to have.

The comparison table

FSAHSA
EligibilityAny employer plan offers itRequires HSA-qualified HDHP
2026 limit$3,400 (health care)$4,400 self / $8,750 family
2027 limitTBA (announced each November)$4,500 self / $9,000 family (official)
Money expires?Yes — year-end, grace period, or $680 carryoverNever — rolls forever
Access to full amountDay one (employer fronts it)Only what's actually deposited
Portable between jobs?No — usually ends at terminationYes — it's yours
Earns interest / investingRarelyYes — interest and investments
Early non-medical withdrawalJust forfeits what's unspentTax + 20% penalty (before 65)
Changes mid-yearLocked except life eventsContribute anytime up to tax deadline
Employer can contribute?RarelyOften — and it counts toward your limit

Can you hold both at once? The rules that cost people real money

The rule that settles it for most people

One exception that changes everything: if your employer's HSA charges monthly maintenance fees or pays 0.01% on cash with no investment option, the "superior" HSA can underperform a plain FSA election in practice. The account type is half the decision — the custodian's terms are the other half.
Whichever you chose — the spending rules are similar: the eligible-expenses list →

More on this site

FSA Deadlines

The FSA's biggest weakness, dated.

FSA Limits 2026

$3,400 / $680 / $7,500.

Use It or Lose It

The spend-down playbook.

Surprising Items

The yes/no list.

HSA Limits 2027

$4,500 / $9,000 — official.

HSARates.com

The HSA interest-rate table.

Sources: IRS Pub 969 · Rev. Proc. 2026-24 (2027 HSA limits) · Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (2026 FSA limits). Independent educational resource; not tax advice.